Why I Lived So Long

by Fangala the Flying Feline

Published April 12, 2007

In Poetry

I'm not good enough for heaven,
I'm not bad enough for hell,
and I might go somewhere in between,
but Purgatory's full.

Comments & reviews · 10
User avatar
lulu_lizzrd
Comment
lulu_lizzrd commented Comment · Jan 7, 2008

ok so far i have liked all your work! your funny and extreamly original! its good to see something new!

lulu

ps hope to see more!!!!!

User avatar
Jasmine Hart
Review
Jasmine Hart wrote a review Review · Jan 6, 2008

Critique two of five. This one is very short, so there's only so much I can say here. I apologise for that, I just chose this one as you said you'd prefer me to look at some of the older material, and I think I'm better at critiquing poetry, so that's what I'm trying to stick with.

I agree with Meep about the half rhyme. (Words that rhyme with "hell" off the top of my head: bell, cell, fell, tell, well.)

This was a straight-forward little piece, and you said what you set out to say, but could you try showing us rather than telling us? Coule you maybe suggest that you're "not good enough for heaven" and "not bad enough for hell" by giving us images and examples, that is to say, suggest it rather than state it?


Hope this helps.

Jas

User avatar
Meep
Comment
Meep commented Comment · Oct 5, 2007

I like it, except the almost-rhyme between "hell" and "full" rubs me the wrong way. Is there any way you could re-word it to avoid that? (You don't have to, really, it's probably a matter of personal preference.)

EnchantressMuffin wrote a review Review · Oct 5, 2007

I read your piece, "Ode To Burnt Toast", and I liked it so much that I figured that all your poetry much be awesome. So, when I saw this, I opened it without a second thought.

It did not disappoint. :)

Peace, love, chocolate.
Muffin

User avatar
Gadi.
Comment
Gadi. commented Comment · Oct 2, 2007

Sweet. Too short to write a full review on, but this is the sort of thing that makes you smile. :D

User avatar
Fael57
Comment
Fael57 commented Comment · Apr 19, 2007

It's kind of short, but I get the point of what you are trying to say.

User avatar
miyaviloves
Review
miyaviloves wrote a review Review · Apr 19, 2007

Hmm, sorry to say but I didn't like this, just becuase it's short I think you have not given it what it deserves. I dunno, to me it was just a peice of writing plonked there, it didn't mean anything and well It might just be me but meh.

Maybe make it longer? Like keep this bit, or add more to it?

Meevs
x

User avatar
Flemzo
Review
Flemzo wrote a review Review · Apr 12, 2007

Woo. Short.

This could definitely use some expansion. What exactly did the narrator do to make him/her think this way? There definitely seems like there's a backstory that we need to know in order to truly know where you're coming from.

... What am I saying? I love short poetry (it's not as much to read, and it keeps my interest).

User avatar
Alainna
Comment
Alainna commented Comment · Apr 12, 2007

Ahh, sweet.
Could there be more to this?

Great work,
Alainna
xxxx



Don't sit down and write because you're a writer; sit down and write because you have something to say. And if the sea of ideas isn't flowing, well, just tell me about your day.
— OrabellaAvenue